SUV Buyer's Guide

Car-Based or Truck-Based?

by SUE MEAD AND MATTHEW DE PAULA, ForbesAutos.com

One of the most important factors — and arguably the first to consider — when buying an SUV is whether to go with one that's built like a truck or one that's built like a car. This decision alone will narrow your options considerably.

Ladder Frame
SUVs are built one of two ways: either on a ladder frame, or as a “unibody”. The method of construction is important to understand because it dictates handling, towing, comfort, four-wheel-drive characteristics, on- and off-road prowess, among other things.

An SUV is said to be built like a truck — or truck-based — if it has a ladder frame, which many pickups and other trucks employ. An SUV is said to be built like a car — or car-based — if it employs a unibody, which most modern cars employ. SUVs built on unibodies are sometimes called "crossovers" because they're like a cross between a car and truck.

See the chart below and accompanying slideshow for the attributes of car- and truck-based SUVs to find out which one is right for you.


How do They Compare?

TRUCK-BASED
CAR-BASED (Crossover)
Ladder frame or "body on frame" construction — like a truck
Unibody or "unit-body" construction — like a car
Highest possible towing and hauling capabilities
Towing and hauling capabilities can be limited
Excellent off-road capability
Off-road capability can be limited
Tend to have a rougher, jittery ride on-road
Tend to be more refined, comfortable and handle better on-road
Best choice if you frequently tow a big boat or venture onto rough terrain.
Best choice if you don't need to tow more than 5,000 lbs. and rarely, if ever, go off-road.
Examples include:
Examples include:
Chevrolet Tahoe/Suburban
Hummer H3
Nissan Armada
Saab 9-7X
BMW X3 and X5
Honda Element
Mercedes-Benz M-Class
Volvo XC90

Next:  Size Matters  
 
 

New-Car Pricing

Get a free online price quote from a dealer near you: